DialIdol.com Forums - Then & Now: Ranking the final 13

Latest Events:

Congratulations Candice Glover - your 2013 American Idol!

Show:

DialIdol.com Forums

Username:	Password:
Save Password Forgot your Password?

All Forums

TV Shows

American Idol ® : The Jurors Room

Then & Now: Ranking the final 13

New Topic

Topic Locked

Printer Friendly

Author

Topic

carriedaway

292 Posts

Posted - 05/25/2012 : 09:27:21 AM

I thought it was a good thread before it fell victim to the black hole.

I didn't get a chance to post mine before it disappeared but since I took the time to compile a list, I'll post it now.

Pre-finals:

1. Hollie
2. Jessica
3. Skylar
4. Joshua
5. Colton
6. Heejun
7. Shannon
8. Elise
9. Phillip
10. Erika
11. Jeremy
12. DeAndre
13. Jermaine

Post-finals:

1. Hollie
2. Jessica
3. Joshua
4. Colton
5. Skylar
6. Elise (loved "Whole Lotta Love")
7. Jermaine (sympathy leap? Seemed like his song the week he was forced out would've been a good one...that's my lasting impression)
8. Phillip
9. DeAndre
10. Erika
11. Heejun
12. Shannon (lasting impression: she was horrendous in the finals)
13. Jeremy (terrible, except when signing "I Know You Won't")

millergal

USA
281 Posts

Posted - 05/25/2012 : 3:13:10 PM

Here's how I initially ranked them in the DI Experts poll, so at least I got the final top two right.

1. Jessica
2. Phillip
3. Hollie
4. Skylar
5. Erika
6. Colton
7. Heejun
8. Deandre
9. Joshua
10. Elise
11. Shannon
12. Jeremy
13. Jermaine

and now:

1. Elise
2. Hollie
3. Jessica
4. Joshua (he has that great voice; still hate the screaming)
5. Colton
6. Skylar
7. Phillip
8. Erika
9. Jermaine
10. Jeremy
11. Deandre
12. Heejun
13. Shannon (painful!)
8. Deandre
11. Shannon

Topic

New Topic

Topic Locked

Printer Friendly

DialIdol.com Forums

Snitz Forums 2000

DialIdol.com is NOT affiliated in any way with FOX TV ®, AMERICAN IDOL ®, or FremantleMedia North America, Inc.