DialIdol.com Forums
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 TV Shows
 American Idol ® : The Jurors Room
 In the following finales...
 New Topic  Topic Locked
 Printer Friendly

Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

guitarman8484

USA
1065 Posts

Posted - 04/23/2012 :  11:06:15 AM  Show Profile
Who would you vote for? Which one would be your ideal and which one would you not want at all costs?

Phillip & Jessica-

Phillip & Joshua-

Phillip & Elise-

Phillip & Hollie-

Phillip & Skylar-

Jessica & Joshua-

Jessica & Elise-

Jessica & Hollie-

Jessica & Skylar-

Skylar & Joshua-

Skylar & Elise-

Skylar & Hollie-

Joshua & Elise-

Joshua & Hollie-

Hollie & Elise-

These are all the possibilities if you didn't figure that out. My voting picks:

Phillip & Jessica- Jessica

Phillip & Joshua- Joshua

Phillip & Elise- Phillip

Phillip & Hollie- Phillip

Phillip & Skylar- Skylar

Jessica & Joshua- Joshua

Jessica & Elise- Jessica

Jessica & Hollie- Jessica

Jessica & Skylar- Skylar

Skylar & Joshua- Skylar

Skylar & Elise- Skylar

Skylar & Hollie- Skylar

Joshua & Elise- Joshua

Joshua & Hollie- Joshua

Hollie & Elise- Hollie

My ideal finale: Skylar and Joshua. Hollie and Elise would be the worst finale ever! I've wanted a Skylar and Phillip duet all season so that would be pretty epic too.

allisonwasrobbed

1308 Posts

Posted - 04/23/2012 :  11:27:00 AM  Show Profile
Ideal finale=Phillip vs Elise
Worst finale=Skylar vs Jessica(I would not even watch that mess)

Rule of thumb:
under no circumstances would I vote for Jessica,Skylar,Hollie

Elise is still alive, baby!!!!!!!!
Go to Top of Page

Kookamunga

USA
3799 Posts

Posted - 04/23/2012 :  12:26:59 PM  Show Profile
If Joshua was in the finale, I would root for and vote for Joshua.

If Phillip was in the finale, but Joshua was not, I would root for Phillip, but probably wouldn't vote for Phillip - unless he was up against Elise, or Hollie.

If Jessica was in the finale, but not Joshua or Phillip, I'd probably root for her, and only vote for her if she was against Elise, or Hollie.

An ideal finale for me would have been Colton and Joshua, with Colton for the win. That can't happen now. So, with everyone that's left, I'd say Phillip and Joshua would be the next best choice. It would be no where's near as good as Colton/Joshua, but it would be making the best of the situation we're left with.

----------
That's QUEEN Kooky to you!

Edited by - Kookamunga on 04/23/2012 12:29:44 PM
Go to Top of Page

CallMeStella

6253 Posts

Posted - 04/23/2012 :  6:22:15 PM  Show Profile
I don't vote, but I'd prefer it to go this way, based solely on what I've seen and heard so far (things can still change for me because I honestly do not have a favorite - it has fluctuated from week to week and could again). I do have a least favorite and I don't see that changing. So, here goes:

Jessica over anyone with the possible exception of Phillip (so far, I feel Jessica has been earning it more).

Phillip over anyone with the possible exception of Jessica.

Elise would have to step it up to beat out Joshua, and if she did, she could also surpass Hollie. No-brainer for me: Elise over Skylar all day long.

Joshua over Hollie (she has been too inconsistent), he can beat out Elise if she continues to falter and he is definitely a no-brainer over Skylar.

Hollie over Skylar

Skylar over nobody.

Jessica and Phillip look like the two frontrunners right now IMO. Skylar has cemented her spot at the bottom for me. Other than that, things can still change, and that's how I see it going, if only for this week.

I'm a redhead. Deal with it!
Go to Top of Page
Google

UVSinger

USA
9336 Posts

Posted - 04/23/2012 :  9:21:39 PM  Show Profile
Who would you vote for? Which one would be your ideal and which one would you not want at all costs?

Phillip & Jessica-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: this one is tough ... UGH, PHILLIP.

Phillip & Joshua-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: PHILLIP

Phillip & Elise-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: PHILLIP

Phillip & Hollie-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: PHILLIP

Phillip & Skylar-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: SKYLAR

Jessica & Joshua-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: JESSICA

Jessica & Elise-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: JESSICA

Jessica & Hollie-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: JESSICA

Jessica & Skylar-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: UMMMM.... SKYLAR?

Skylar & Joshua-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: SKYLAR

Skylar & Elise-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: SKYLAR

Skylar & Hollie-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: SKYLAR

Joshua & Elise-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: UMMM ... JOSHUA is a better singer, but ELISE picks songs i like. I'm going with ELISE

Joshua & Hollie-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: HOLLIE

Hollie & Elise-
IDEAL/WOULD VOTE FOR: HOLLIE


My ideal finale: At this point, SKYLAR and ??? I GUESS PHILLIP.
Maybe JESSICA.

JOSHUA AND ELISE OR JOSHUA AND HOLLIE would be the worst finale FOR ME.

I think Skylar is becoming my new favorite. Gman would be happy!

Edited by - UVSinger on 04/23/2012 9:23:20 PM
Go to Top of Page

carriedaway

300 Posts

Posted - 04/24/2012 :  09:54:08 AM  Show Profile
Phillip & Jessica- Jessica

Phillip & Joshua- Joshua

Phillip & Elise- Elise

Phillip & Hollie- Hollie

Phillip & Skylar- Skylar

(You can see which one I don't want I guess I wouldn't want the last one the most, although I'm okay with anyone but Phillip).

But I will be shocked if Phillip is not in the final

Jessica & Joshua- Jessica

Jessica & Elise- Jessica

Jessica & Hollie- Hollie

Jessica & Skylar- Jessica

Skylar & Joshua- Joshua

Skylar & Elise- Probably Skylar

Skylar & Hollie- Hollie

Joshua & Elise- Joshua

Joshua & Hollie- Hollie

Hollie & Elise- Hollie


I'd like to see Hollie in the finale, but I know there's a 0% chance of that happening... so I guess my ideal (at least realistic, albeit longshot) finale is Jessica & Joshua.
Go to Top of Page
Your Ad Here

catbert

Uzbekistan
4213 Posts

Posted - 04/25/2012 :  7:27:17 PM  Show Profile
This thread is a convoluted mess.

Here go hell come.
Go to Top of Page

chrisgatz17

22 Posts

Posted - 04/25/2012 :  11:15:43 PM  Show Profile
Phillip & Jessica-Jessica

Phillip & Joshua-.....Joshua

Phillip & Elise-Elise

Phillip & Hollie-Hollie

Phillip & Skylar-Skylar

Jessica & Joshua-Jessica

Jessica & Elise-Jessica

Jessica & Hollie-Hollie (But Jessica would surly win)

Jessica & Skylar-Skylar

Skylar & Joshua-Skylar

Skylar & Elise-Skylar

Skylar & Hollie-Skylar

Joshua & Elise-Elise

Joshua & Hollie-Hollie

Hollie & Elise-Hollie
Go to Top of Page

Lancelot of Camelot

3305 Posts

Posted - 04/25/2012 :  11:41:31 PM  Show Profile
quote:
Originally posted by chrisgatz17

Phillip & Jessica-Jessica

Phillip & Joshua-.....Joshua

Phillip & Elise-Elise

Phillip & Hollie-Hollie

Phillip & Skylar-Skylar

Jessica & Joshua-Jessica

Jessica & Elise-Jessica

Jessica & Hollie-Hollie (But Jessica would surly win)

Jessica & Skylar-Skylar

Skylar & Joshua-Skylar

Skylar & Elise-Skylar

Skylar & Hollie-Skylar

Joshua & Elise-Elise

Joshua & Hollie-Hollie

Hollie & Elise-Hollie




To answer this question here is my order so you can take it from there.

Jessica
Joshua
Hollie
Skylar
Elise
Phillip

Notice how after tonights performances my top three remained the same but I switched around the bottom three completely.
Go to Top of Page

Roimeister

14228 Posts

Posted - 04/25/2012 :  11:43:41 PM  Show Profile
quote:
Originally posted by Lancelot of Camelot


To answer this question here is my order so you can take it from there.

Jessica
Joshua
Hollie
Skylar
Elise
Phillip

Notice how after tonights performances my top three remained the same but I switched around the bottom three completely.



that is SO much less of a hot mess than the other responses are
Go to Top of Page

Lancelot of Camelot

3305 Posts

Posted - 04/25/2012 :  11:48:19 PM  Show Profile
quote:
Originally posted by Roimeister

quote:
Originally posted by Lancelot of Camelot


To answer this question here is my order so you can take it from there.

Jessica
Joshua
Hollie
Skylar
Elise
Phillip

Notice how after tonights performances my top three remained the same but I switched around the bottom three completely.



that is SO much less of a hot mess than the other responses are



Do I get props for that?
Go to Top of Page

Roimeister

14228 Posts

Posted - 04/25/2012 :  11:48:46 PM  Show Profile
quote:
Originally posted by Lancelot of Camelot

quote:
Originally posted by Roimeister

quote:
Originally posted by Lancelot of Camelot


To answer this question here is my order so you can take it from there.

Jessica
Joshua
Hollie
Skylar
Elise
Phillip

Notice how after tonights performances my top three remained the same but I switched around the bottom three completely.



that is SO much less of a hot mess than the other responses are



Do I get props for that?



MAJOR props!
Go to Top of Page

TheRealDeal83

USA
9 Posts

Posted - 04/26/2012 :  12:05:56 AM  Show Profile
Phillip & Jessica - Jessica

Phillip & Joshua- Joshua

Phillip & Elise- Elise

Phillip & Hollie- Hollie

Phillip & Skylar- Phillip

Jessica & Joshua- Jessica

Jessica & Elise- Jessica

Jessica & Hollie- Jessica

Jessica & Skylar- Jessica

Skylar & Joshua- Skylar

Skylar & Elise- Elise

Skylar & Hollie- Skylar

Joshua & Elise- Joshua

Joshua & Hollie- Joshua

Hollie & Elise - Hollie
Go to Top of Page

Roimeister

14228 Posts

Posted - 04/26/2012 :  12:10:58 AM  Show Profile
quote:
Originally posted by TheRealDeal83

Phillip & Jessica - Jessica

Phillip & Joshua- Joshua

Phillip & Elise- Elise

Phillip & Hollie- Hollie

Phillip & Skylar- Phillip

Jessica & Joshua- Jessica

Jessica & Elise- Jessica

Jessica & Hollie- Jessica

Jessica & Skylar- Jessica

Skylar & Joshua- Skylar

Skylar & Elise- Elise

Skylar & Hollie- Skylar

Joshua & Elise- Joshua

Joshua & Hollie- Joshua

Hollie & Elise - Hollie




****in A, Bubba!

still a hot mess but I gotta give you props for color coding...
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Topic Locked
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
DialIdol.com Forums © www.DialIdol.com Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000
Google
DialIdol.com is NOT affiliated in any way with FOX TV ®, AMERICAN IDOL ®, or FremantleMedia North America, Inc.